Lore

Continuity Issues

Conflicting details and apparent contradictions across the Spellmonger series

A running log of places in the books where details seem to change or disagree. Each entry quotes the passages involved and, where possible, offers candidate reconciliations — the goal is to track them carefully, not to declare the author wrong.

Items & Artefacts

Objects whose description changes between books.

Staff of the Archmage — physical relic or Constructed Intelligence?
Item Possible Retcon
In Book 1 the Staff of the Archmage is name-checked as a legendary physical weapon alongside Defender-of-Empires. By Book 12, Lilastien reveals it was never a staff at all — it was a Level Five Constructed Intelligence that governed Leden City on Perwyn.
Stonetrunk's Heart — Separate Article Suggested
Item Open
Stonetrunk's Heart is currently documented only as a component of Tanno Amberil. The reviewer suggests a dedicated article covering the adventure to obtain it and its significance as a Leshi relic, with Tanno Amberil then documented separately as the staff.

Characters

Facts about people — relationships, children, loyalties, ages — that shift.

Astyral: Castali Gilmoran by Birth, Alshari by Allegiance
Character Open
Astyral is Gilmoran by birth in Castali-controlled territory, but his allegiance and lands progressively shift toward Alshar across the series. The smh_chars nation field should be reviewed once his formal transfer is confirmed in the later books.
Fallawen's Kindred: Avalanti or Versaroti?
Character Open
Fallawen is widely tagged as Avalanti, but Necromancer explicitly declares the House of Aeratas to be of the Versaroti kindred — and Fallawen is Lord Aeratas's daughter. The books never once call her Avalanti.
Mavone Cousin Contradiction (Warmage)
Character Open
Warmage's narrator explicitly states that only Curmor and Astyral are related among the Gilmoran trio, yet in the same book Mavone refers to Curmor as 'my cousin.' Thaumaturge later places Mavone's cousin as Astyral, adding a third inconsistent data point.
Mavone-Gilmoran Kinship Contradiction
Character Possible Retcon
Warmage states that among the three Gilmoran warmagi only Curmor and Astyral were related (distant cousins), explicitly excluding Mavone. Thaumaturge later shows Mavone referring to Astyral as his cousin, directly contradicting the earlier text.
Minalan's unaccounted-for children
Character Open
In Book 7 Ishi tells Minalan there are three of his bastards in the world he's never met. Readers recall the goddesses later cite a higher count — despite Minalan's stated loyalty to Alya after the Isily trauma of Book 7.
Rondal's disappearing witchstone
Character Open
Rondal takes a witchstone at the fall of Boval Castle in Book 1 — but in early Book 2 he appears to be stoneless again, without any explanation of where the stone went in between.
Terleman Nationality Unverified
Character Open
No book passage establishes Terleman as Castali. The reviewer's recollection of a coastal or Farisen connection appears to stem from the Farisian Campaign setting, not a stated origin.

Timeline & Sequence

Dates, durations, and sequences of events.

"Fifth year" of Rard's reign in Footwizard vs "9th year" in Mad Mage
Timeline Open
Book 13 has Tyndal say "we are in the fifth year of his reign," but Book 14.5 — which immediately follows — explicitly stamps the date as the 9th year of King Rard I's reign. The two anchors are four years apart with no intervening time-jump narrated.

Names & Spellings

Places and people whose names drift across books.

Alaran Stone vs Allaran Stone spelling
Name / Spelling Open
Theurge consistently spells it Alaran Stone (11 mentions, one L); the wiki's existing entry is Allaran Stone (two Ls). Determine the canonical spelling and align the wiki entry.
Lord Aeratas in Practical Adept — author typo?
Name / Spelling Resolved
In Book 17 Chapter One, the text attributes a Beryen Council line to "Lord Aeratas" — but he's been sealed into a Kulla Alon body in the Cavern of Ages since Book 10. The audiobook reads it the same way, so the error is in the source manuscript. Resolved as a typo for Letharan.
Pentandra's Father: Orisorio vs. Osirigo
Name / Spelling Possible Retcon
Pentandra's father is named 'Orisorio' in most appearances but 'Osirigo' in Books 1 and 2, suggesting an early authorial inconsistency that was quietly corrected as the series progressed.
📖 Get the Books

The Spellmonger series by Terry Mancour is available in audiobook, ebook, and paperback.

Audiobooks are produced by Podium Entertainment and narrated by Tim Gerard Reynolds.

Browse on Podium Entertainment →